5 thoughts on “My review of Matthew B. Crawford’s “Shop Class as Soulcraft””

  1. “Because assembly-line work demanded little of a worker other than submissive patience, it did not focus his attention and felt meaningless in the moment.”

    I hated thinking about how much this applies to contemporary office work, but I really loved this review, Caleb–so thoughtful and elegant.

  2. A better review than the piece about The Pleasures and Sorrows of Work … which shows a deep misunderstanding of the British attitudes towards work, eccentricity, and humor … to state that 'Either geeking out is shameful or it isn't' is a purely American perspective, the cultural hegemony behind the unquestioned assumption that motivations and values are the same across these two cultures is disappointing.

  3. Excellent review. A small objection: when you say "Ph.D.s", it is important to remember that a quite large percentage of Ph.D.s are in the sciences – and these often involve experimental (hands-on) and intellectual work.
    At their best, these jobs really do live up to Crawford's hopes. Which is exactly why I have been unable to convince myself to do something less engaging for more money…

Comments are closed.